First of all I have to say that I’ve really enjoyed the module and that the blog, that at the beginning gave me some concerns, has been a useful tool to share ideas with my colleagues and to express my ideas. Thanks to the participants, who made the blog an interesting and stimulating activity, and to Steven Curtis who allowed us to get involved in a different approach to our studies than the usual academic one.
The module gave me the opportunity to learn how states interact with each others through their diplomatic machinery, either publicly and secretly. In fact though I do not share the idea that secret diplomacy is fair, especially in democratic societies, I’ve understood that sometimes it is the only tool to resolve international crisis, as the Cuban Missile Crisis shows. In fact in this situation backchannels played a fundamental role to escape a nuclear war (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/apr/16/anatoly-dobrynin-obituary, for the role of Anatoly Dobrynin as key actors to resolve crises through backchannels).
Moreover the module has been helpful to clarify the role played by NGOs and non state actors in diplomatic talks, and their ability to matter in the international scenario, since they can lobby for the issues at stake for their interests; I found an interesting case of an Italian NGO, Emergency, which successfully lobbed, conducting a parallel diplomacy, to realise some of its members arrested in Afghanistan for the allegation of being involved in a conspiracy against the government (for more details see http://it.peacereporter.net/articolo/21433/Emergency%2C+da+piazza+San+Giovanni, if you need translation contact me). The NGO brought a considerable number of people on the streets to protest for the event and carried diplomatic talks with both the Afghan Foreign and Home Secretaries and with the Afghan vice-president as well (ibid.), and eventually succeeded in obtaining its members’ realise. This case clearly shows that nowadays NGOs have a greater role on the international relations, especially thanks to their “parallel Diplomacy”.
Furthermore throughout the module I understood that nowadays diplomats are no longer the only ones who conduct diplomacy, common people are more involved in it especially in public diplomacy, as Mark Leonard says “Britain has 60 million budding ambassadors” (Leonard and Alakeson, 2000) . In fact the latter is aimed at addressing the people, because especially in democratic society they are able to restrain their governments, and their governments have to please them.
Overall the module has been helpful in clarifying the importance of diplomacy in the present days. It is an effective tool to further the interests of the states, as public diplomacy shows, and of non-state actors as well, which carry a parallel, but still relevant, diplomacy. It is a tool to cooperate and reach agreements on an international level, as the case of multilateral diplomacy on environment demonstrates. And finally it could be the most powerful tool to overcome wars, and even prevent them.
Though it is important to bear in mind that despite diplomatic efforts to come together, states ultimately emphasize their national interests and diplomacy is the main tool they use to do it and that is why sometimes is so difficult to reach diplomatic agreements.
Leonard M. and Alakeson V., 2000, “Going Public: Diplomacy for the Information Society”, Foreign Policy Centre.
Showing posts with label federica. Show all posts
Showing posts with label federica. Show all posts
Wednesday, 28 April 2010
Friday, 16 April 2010
Rethinking secret diplomacy: a good citizen need to be informed

In today’s seminar we discussed about secrecy in diplomacy and almost unanimously we agreed that secret negotiations can be useful to manage difficult situations of crisis, as the Cuban Missile Crisis showed. However during the seminar discussion a question came up in my mind. Is it fair that the population, and let it say I’m talking about us, citizens, people, individuals, live happy lives ignoring what is going on around us? Is it fair that we are “amused to death” (Postman, 1985), to use Neil Postman expression, distract by TV shows, celebrity gossip, sex, the myth of the wealthy life, and sleazy issues while our governments enhance their interests which often do not reflect ours as citizens?
Personally I would say NO, it is not fair! Secret negotiations are acceptable in situation of crisis but not in decision-making process that concern our lives as citizens.
Let me provide two examples for my argument. First the Lisbon Treaty, how many EU citizens know what does the Lisbon Treaty state? I would say a very little minority of us. Everybody talks about it, but barely none knows how is gonna affect our lives. And let me say that I do not blame us, I would rather blame the governments that are keeping secret it.
The second example I would provide is the secret negotiations surrounding the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreements (ACTA), carried by the EU, USA and Japan where anything has been published (Digital Majority, 2009 http://www.digitalmajority.org/forum/t-146371/secret-european-union-mandate-to-negotiate-acta-leaked:fears-confirmed) and which will have great impact on our lives. There are concerns that ACTA may “limit access to medicines, limit access to the internet, give patent trolls free reign and harm the most innovative sectors of the economy” (ibid.), however the public is not being informed about it and negotiations are running behind closed doors, so that when everything will be agreed and negotiated, ACTA will be implemented and the population will not have a say about it. It seems all too logic no?
I’m not arguing against secret diplomacy a priori, I just want to underline that it cannot be the norm. Citizens need to be informed in order to be good citizens, otherwise we will continue to worry about trivial matters, to fill our lives with vanity and leave what really matters in elite groups’ hands, keeping on calling all of this democracy.
Pericle, a General of the ancient Athens, between 461 BC and 429 BC, understood something more than us about democracy and he showed it with this speech:
“Here in Athens we do like this, our government favours the many instead of the few; this is why it is called democracy.
Here in Athens we do like this, the laws, here, afford equal justice to all in their private differences; but we never ignore reputation for capacity.
When a citizen has shown himself worthy, he will be, upon others, favored to serve the state, not as a privilege, but as a reward for worth, and poverty doesn’t bar the way.
Here in Athens we do like this. The freedom which we enjoy, extends also to our ordinary life.There, far from exercising a jealous surveillance over each other, we do not feel called upon to be angry with our neighbour for doing what he likes. We are free, free to live exactly as we please, and yet are just as ready to encounter every legitimate danger.
Here in Athens we do like this: we have been taught, to respect magistrates, and we have been taught to obey the laws, and never to forget those who have been injured. And we have been taught to respect that code which, although unwritten, is based upon the universal feeling of what is right, and cannot be broken without acknowledged disgrace.
Here in Athens we do like this: we see him who takes no interest in public matters not as unambitious but as useless, and although few are able to originate a politics, we all athenians are able to judge it. We don’t look on discussion as a stumbling-block in the way to democracy.
We believe that happiness originates from freedom, but freedom only originates from courage.
In short, I say Athens school of Hellas, and that every Athenians shows in himself a happy flexibility, self trust, and readiness to face any situation. And this is why we throw open our city and never by alien acts exclude foreigners.” (Pericle quoted in Pietro Speroni http://blog.pietrosperoni.it/2006/07/13/here-in-athens-we-do-like-this/)
(for the full speech look at the Pietro Speroni web site http://blog.pietrosperoni.it/2006/07/13/here-in-athens-we-do-like-this/)
Tuesday, 13 April 2010
purposeful tool for the new diplomacy


Diplomacy is a practice that underwent several changes over time and is still evolving, accommodating the changing global environment. Currently two main issues are affecting diplomacy as a result of its increased openness, inclusiveness and its engagement with low politics matters: the emergence of non-state actors in the diplomatic communication and the increasing relevance of multilateral diplomacy.
Nowadays non-state actors, such as NGOs, are acquiring more relevance in the international scenario, either because states are sometimes unable to deal with some issues, e.g. failed states, or because some issues are becoming increasingly internationalized, e.g. human rights, environmental problems etc. For the same reasons non-state actors are engaging more with diplomatic actions, as Richard Longhorne states “when crisis seem to lie beyond the control of governments or the relevant intergovernmental organizations, non-state actors come to play significant roles”(Longhorne, 2005, 332) and they are able to “transcend the constrains of the state” (ibid.).
One example which shows the importance of NGOs diplomacy is Greenpeace winning the diplomatic war over whales fishing in Japan in 2006.
http://weblog.greenpeace.org/oceandefenders/archive/2006/06/wake_up_and_smell_the_cof.html.
The other important aspect of the new diplomacy is its multilateralism which is a diplomatic communication undertaken by several governments simultaneously (Walker, 2004, 16).
As said above, many global issues are crossing the states’ borders, and a pooled diplomacy can be an useful to gain mutual benefits and tackle cross border issues such as pollution or poverty.
The Non-Aligned Movement is a good example of multilateral diplomacy, and though during its existence faced problems related to the hegemonic and hierarchical structure of the international system (not only, but also internal problems due to lack of consent and consistency), it highlights an important development: it allowed weak states to have a diplomatic machinery which otherwise would have been completely absent. Moreover multilateral diplomacy allow weak states to have a seat together with the powerful ones and could permit the former to be treated equally and fairly; as Walker says “ the weak need the powerful more than vice-versa” (Walker, 2004, 25), but the powerful should leave more room for the weak for the multilateral diplomacy to work properly and fairly.
Overall diplomacy is evolving and implementing its tactics, though it is not abandoning the old practice such as bilateral diplomacy or secrecy.
However this is just the base, in fact both NGOs diplomacy and multilateral diplomacy must be improved to meet relevant goals.
Most of all, NGOs must affirm their legitimacy and multilateral conferences must not be driven by plutocracy.
Both of them are purposeful tool for diplomacy, however they need the spur to develop and improve.
Longhorne R, 2005, “The Diplomacy of Non-State Actors”, in Diplomacy and Statecraft, Vol.16, No.2, Routledge Taylor & Francis.
Walker R, 2004, “Multilateral Conferences: Purposeful International Negotiation”, Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire.
Wednesday, 24 March 2010
China's public diplomacy: understanding the importance
Lets leave the arguable public diplomacy of the United States, and the arrogant one of Israel; today I would like to present a little of China’s public diplomacy.
China is one of the biggest countries, with 1.34 billion people, a thousand-years culture and its economy is boosting. (For further details see http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/country_profiles/1287798.stm). However, as Ingrid d’Hooghe states, China is facing problems related to its image, and the opposition of the global public opinion over issues such as pollution, human rights abuses, the Tibet issue, its policies toward Taiwan and Hong Kong, its military force (d‘Hooghe, 2007, 14), the smuggling of nuclear material and its one party regime. D’Hooghe argues that China is addressing the public opinion through public diplomacy manoeuvred by the Office of Foreign Propaganda of the Chinese Communist Party and the Information Office (d’Hooghe, 2007, 21), which exercise great control over the local media.
The fact that the Chinese government exercises authority over its diplomatic machinery says much of the importance of public diplomacy in the contemporary world and I would like to analyse it through the main goals the Chinese public diplomacy is aimed at. In the d’Hooghe’s diplomatic paper is stated that the main goals of the Chinese public diplomacy are to be seen as a country committed to create an “harmonious society” within it, to be seen as good economic partner, to be seen as a force for peace in the international community and finally to be acknowledged as an ancient and vibrant culture ( d’Hooghe, 2007, 18). Someone would argue that those are quite high level goals for a one-party-state which makes full use of the death penalty and of the birth control, which is accused to perpetrate the recent economic crisis because of its currency policy (http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSN2324379920100323), and which vetoed the intervention in Darfur and more recently in Sri-Lanka and is itself involved in the Tibet question.
However China understood that with a good rhetoric it can cover the problems or shift the attention from those issues, especially when supported by censorship and a restrained access to the territory, and that is what its public diplomacy is mainly aimed at.
China has always had a special care of the control of its informative media but especially of the foreign media, which are blamed by the Chinese government to be the main responsible of China’s bad image in the world, arguing that they show just the bad face of China (d’Hooghe, 2007, 17).
The main threat for China is the Internet, which is the most difficult media to control. To address the problem, following Google refusal to contribute to the Chinese censorship, the Chinese government is deciding to shut it down so restraining the information of its citizens as well as limiting the exchange of opinion from the latter to the foreign public.
So doing China constrains others’ public diplomacy, fearing that, knowing inconvenient stories from abroad, its citizen can raise against the government, and prevents its “public diplomats” to express negative view of the country. In fact, it can be argued that since public diplomacy is an important tool for self-presentation, and China is facing many problems with its image abroad, it has to be careful of any information coming in and going out from the country, and a public diplomacy fully under state control reduces the chance to present a bad image of the country.
From the example of China we can understand the importance of self-presentation through the public diplomacy, and that, especially when words are not supported by actions, a state-controlled public diplomacy is required to direct the public opinion, as we have seen in the US public diplomacy after the 9/11 through the Shared Values Campaign which was under government control.
For further details on China and Google see:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/mar/23/google-china-firewall-censorship-internet
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/01/13/AR2010011302908.html
For further details on China and the media censorship see:
http://www.cfr.org/publication/11515/
For d'Hooghe diplomatic paper see:
http://www.clingendael.nl/publications/2007/20070700_cdsp_paper_hooghe.pdf
China is one of the biggest countries, with 1.34 billion people, a thousand-years culture and its economy is boosting. (For further details see http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/country_profiles/1287798.stm). However, as Ingrid d’Hooghe states, China is facing problems related to its image, and the opposition of the global public opinion over issues such as pollution, human rights abuses, the Tibet issue, its policies toward Taiwan and Hong Kong, its military force (d‘Hooghe, 2007, 14), the smuggling of nuclear material and its one party regime. D’Hooghe argues that China is addressing the public opinion through public diplomacy manoeuvred by the Office of Foreign Propaganda of the Chinese Communist Party and the Information Office (d’Hooghe, 2007, 21), which exercise great control over the local media.
The fact that the Chinese government exercises authority over its diplomatic machinery says much of the importance of public diplomacy in the contemporary world and I would like to analyse it through the main goals the Chinese public diplomacy is aimed at. In the d’Hooghe’s diplomatic paper is stated that the main goals of the Chinese public diplomacy are to be seen as a country committed to create an “harmonious society” within it, to be seen as good economic partner, to be seen as a force for peace in the international community and finally to be acknowledged as an ancient and vibrant culture ( d’Hooghe, 2007, 18). Someone would argue that those are quite high level goals for a one-party-state which makes full use of the death penalty and of the birth control, which is accused to perpetrate the recent economic crisis because of its currency policy (http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSN2324379920100323), and which vetoed the intervention in Darfur and more recently in Sri-Lanka and is itself involved in the Tibet question.
However China understood that with a good rhetoric it can cover the problems or shift the attention from those issues, especially when supported by censorship and a restrained access to the territory, and that is what its public diplomacy is mainly aimed at.
China has always had a special care of the control of its informative media but especially of the foreign media, which are blamed by the Chinese government to be the main responsible of China’s bad image in the world, arguing that they show just the bad face of China (d’Hooghe, 2007, 17).
The main threat for China is the Internet, which is the most difficult media to control. To address the problem, following Google refusal to contribute to the Chinese censorship, the Chinese government is deciding to shut it down so restraining the information of its citizens as well as limiting the exchange of opinion from the latter to the foreign public.
So doing China constrains others’ public diplomacy, fearing that, knowing inconvenient stories from abroad, its citizen can raise against the government, and prevents its “public diplomats” to express negative view of the country. In fact, it can be argued that since public diplomacy is an important tool for self-presentation, and China is facing many problems with its image abroad, it has to be careful of any information coming in and going out from the country, and a public diplomacy fully under state control reduces the chance to present a bad image of the country.
From the example of China we can understand the importance of self-presentation through the public diplomacy, and that, especially when words are not supported by actions, a state-controlled public diplomacy is required to direct the public opinion, as we have seen in the US public diplomacy after the 9/11 through the Shared Values Campaign which was under government control.
For further details on China and Google see:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/mar/23/google-china-firewall-censorship-internet
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/01/13/AR2010011302908.html
For further details on China and the media censorship see:
http://www.cfr.org/publication/11515/
For d'Hooghe diplomatic paper see:
http://www.clingendael.nl/publications/2007/20070700_cdsp_paper_hooghe.pdf
Friday, 19 March 2010
is american public diplomacy mere propaganda?
Given the fact that propaganda is a broad term, which creats debates over its definition, let assume that it is the form of communication designed to influence others' behavior for self interests, to quote the literature propaganda is defined by Garth Jowett and Victoria O'Donnell as "the deliberate and systematic attempt to shape perceptions, manipulate cognitions and direct behaviors to achieve a response that furthers the intent of the propagandist" (Jowett and O'Donnell, 1992, 4). let also say that it relies on symbols, myths and irrational emotions.
Assumed that, relying on the definition you prefer for public diplomacy, i'd like you to think about the US public diplomacy over the last 60-70 years, about the role of the USIA and the Voice Of America during the cold war, the Shared Values Campaign, and Obama self-presentation and the rebranding of USA under his presidency, about the Hollywood's presentation of the American dream and finally on the americanization of the world that occurred since the end of the Cold War, then think about America victimizing itself after the 9/11 attacks and its campaign to support its illegal war on Iraq waged for the alleged possesion of Iraqi weapons of mass destruction, which ectually have never been found, and finally about the war on terror which is actually spreading more terror on us and increasing terror (Snow, 2009, 34).
Now you might think that I am doing counterpropaganda, however I just want to ask you whether you believe or not that american public diplomacy is propaganda. it is a kind of survey nothing more that that.
thanks
Assumed that, relying on the definition you prefer for public diplomacy, i'd like you to think about the US public diplomacy over the last 60-70 years, about the role of the USIA and the Voice Of America during the cold war, the Shared Values Campaign, and Obama self-presentation and the rebranding of USA under his presidency, about the Hollywood's presentation of the American dream and finally on the americanization of the world that occurred since the end of the Cold War, then think about America victimizing itself after the 9/11 attacks and its campaign to support its illegal war on Iraq waged for the alleged possesion of Iraqi weapons of mass destruction, which ectually have never been found, and finally about the war on terror which is actually spreading more terror on us and increasing terror (Snow, 2009, 34).
Now you might think that I am doing counterpropaganda, however I just want to ask you whether you believe or not that american public diplomacy is propaganda. it is a kind of survey nothing more that that.
thanks
Tuesday, 16 March 2010
old and new diplomacy undermined by Israel
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/middle_east/article7062807.ece
Today I came across an intereisting news in the Times (link above) about Israel expanding its settlements, building 1,600 homes in East Jerusalem, a district claimed by Palestinians for their future capital. Now, the odd point is not Israel further occupying Palestinian territories, it is doing so since 1948, the point I want to focus at is the fact that Israel is undermining its alliance with the USA. Israel is grown so powerfull that eventually it does not have to rely anymore on USA support; in fact it can be argued that Israel sought USA alliance because it is "a Jewish spot" in the Arab World and, as the past shows, there has been a tense climate between the Arab and the Jewish worlds in the Middle-East. However, as Giles Whittell, the autor of the article, said, "Mr Netanyahu has lost sight of the importance of US-Israeli relations and of the urgent need to build a coalition to isolate Iran before it threatens the region with nuclear weapons".
In this scenario, Israel is undermining its good and favorable relations with USA, its scarse relations with Palestine, worsening the Israel-Palestine issue, the mediatic role of the USA in the region, since Israel and Palestine agreed to negotiate only through the White House special envoy in the the Middle-East, Mr Mitchell, and is dismissing any chance to achieve a peace deal in the region.
Israel is following its line careless of the consequences probabibly because it is aware of its power.
It seems that in this situation diplomacy is a powerless tool; Israel decided not to rely neither on the multilater, new diplomacy, nor in the secret, old diplomacy, nor on the newest public diplomacy, it decided to run alone, and this will eventually pose a seriuos threat on the international sicurity for the foreseeable scenarios.
Today I came across an intereisting news in the Times (link above) about Israel expanding its settlements, building 1,600 homes in East Jerusalem, a district claimed by Palestinians for their future capital. Now, the odd point is not Israel further occupying Palestinian territories, it is doing so since 1948, the point I want to focus at is the fact that Israel is undermining its alliance with the USA. Israel is grown so powerfull that eventually it does not have to rely anymore on USA support; in fact it can be argued that Israel sought USA alliance because it is "a Jewish spot" in the Arab World and, as the past shows, there has been a tense climate between the Arab and the Jewish worlds in the Middle-East. However, as Giles Whittell, the autor of the article, said, "Mr Netanyahu has lost sight of the importance of US-Israeli relations and of the urgent need to build a coalition to isolate Iran before it threatens the region with nuclear weapons".
In this scenario, Israel is undermining its good and favorable relations with USA, its scarse relations with Palestine, worsening the Israel-Palestine issue, the mediatic role of the USA in the region, since Israel and Palestine agreed to negotiate only through the White House special envoy in the the Middle-East, Mr Mitchell, and is dismissing any chance to achieve a peace deal in the region.
Israel is following its line careless of the consequences probabibly because it is aware of its power.
It seems that in this situation diplomacy is a powerless tool; Israel decided not to rely neither on the multilater, new diplomacy, nor in the secret, old diplomacy, nor on the newest public diplomacy, it decided to run alone, and this will eventually pose a seriuos threat on the international sicurity for the foreseeable scenarios.
Sunday, 7 March 2010
embassies and intelligence services: the perpertation of the old diplomacy

The forces of globalization are deeply changing and shaping the international scenario, affecting the individual nation states as well as the way they interact with each others. In fact it can be argued that globalization, promoting a grater interconnectedness among states, is leading to further progresses in the new diplomacy advocated by W. Wilson. This can lead to think that the new diplomacy is taking precedent over the old one, which nowadays can be considered obsolete.
Although it is true that nowadays diplomacy is more open, inclusive and more focused on issues of law politics, it remains, as Morgenthau stated, the main way to promote the national interests by peaceful means 1, and this is why the old diplomacy is still relevant today.
In a world dominated by a realist view, nation states are concerned about matters on national security and want to maximize their national interests, and the main institution of the old diplomacy, the embassy, well serves these aims. In fact, although many scholars argue that embassies are losing their functions, and others, such as Jozef Batora and Brian Hocking 2, claim that embassies are accommodating the occurring changes, the embassies are still the locations of secret information gathering, the meeting point of bilateral relations, and the place where diplomats come to bilateral agreements.
An example supporting the relevance of the old diplomacy in the contemporary scenario is the case of the United States re-engaging diplomatic relations with Syria, re-opening the US embassy in Damascus, with the purpose to cut the Syria-Iran relations, intending to isolating Teheran in order to push the latter to abandon the nuclear programme 3. In this case diplomacy is a matter of high policy, is exclusive, since it is aimed at the isolation of Teheran, and secrecy might play an important role in the negotiations between Washington and Damascus.
The point is that no one can guarantee that "modern Treaty of London" occurs in the contemporary world since many states enjoy the privileges of embassies where secret diplomacy can be undisturbed carried on, supported by intelligence services. In fact it can be argued that the intelligence services and the Official Secret Acts do not encourage an open diplomacy, but reinforce the old one.
Overall, it is true that multilateral diplomacy is acquiring more importance, and the increased number of summits shows this, but this does not mean the irrelevance of the old diplomacy. In fact, as it emerges from the framework presented above, the old diplomacy is perpetrated by the presence of permanent embassies and the the role of the intelligence services, so that it can be argued that old and new diplomacy coexist is the contemporary international system.
1 Russell, R., ‘American Diplomatic Realism: A Tradition Practised and Preached by George F. Kennan’ in , Vol. 11, No. 3, 2000 p 163
2 Jozef Batora and Brian Hocking, “EU-Oriented Bilateralism: Evaluating the Role of Member State Embassies in the European Union”
Wednesday, 3 March 2010
In defense of bilateral diplomacy: the Swedish embassy
Over time states acquired a role of main players in the international arena from the Treaty of Westphalia which set up a state-centred international system to the UN Charter which acknowledged the equal sovereignty of all UN members (1). States have always interacted with each others for a wide range of reasons from trade matters, to economic issues and political confrontations. A great role in this relationship between states has been played by the permanent embassies and by the bilateral diplomacy defined as the “exchange of diplomatic representation between national governments” (2).
However it can be argued that, today, bilateral diplomacy is undermined by multilateralism and globalization as the case of the European diplomatic machinery taking precedent over bilateral diplomacy between EU members shows, posing the question whether EU bilateral missions fit within the European integration (3).
Still there is who oppose this view and today, 3rd of March, it has been interesting listening to the point of view of a diplomat about the role of embassies in the contemporary situation.
A diplomat from the Swedish embassy introduced us with his embassy and presented us the contemporary debate over the role of EU bilateral embassies in an integrated European scenario. He stressed that the people working within the Swedish embassy in London have been considerably reduced since the creation of the European diplomatic machinery has been formally established, especially because many of them have now been transferred to Brussels. In fact since the multilateral European diplomacy took over bilateral diplomacy, enormous budget cuts have been implemented, leaving any room for the specialists and increasing the job for the few diplomats still working for the embassy who have to be able to deal with many and different issues in a general way. Eventually this poses the question whether diplomats with a general, but not specialized, knowledge of the issues can operate in an efficient way as the specialists can do.
Then he argued that, although many people, some of his colleagues as well, question the role of permanent embassies in EU countries, bilateral diplomacy between EU members is a matter of understanding and clarification of European concerns between them, and that now a days European matters are brought to the table, so affirming that the diplomatic service now is not in a situation of vacuum but is accommodating the changing situation. Though, sadly he has to admit that some European embassies are closing down in some European capitals such as the Swedish in Dublin and Luxembourg.
On the second part of the meeting it has been interesting seeing how the Swedish diplomat dealt with our questions about the nature of embassies and the challenges they have to face.
He has been asked about the secret diplomacy that bilateralism encourages and he replayed that, although many countries are deeply involved within it, that is not the case of Sweden which carries a diplomacy as much open as it can.
Another question he has been asked was about the challenges the new technologies poses on diplomacy, yet he argued that physical presence is a key point for diplomatic relations.
He also has been asked whether multilateral diplomacy opposes to the pursuit of the promotion of national interests, and he absolutely agreed with it stating that when the issue is brought to the multilateral table, the outcome never reflects the national interests since it is the result of the “consensus” of the participants.
Overall it has been interesting listening to a diplomat, well aware of the debates going on about the role of bilateralism, defending his position in this challenging environment, stressing the understanding of the culture and hot issues that permanent embassies allow. In fact, though it can be argued that Europeans share a common history, culture and environment, we are very different state from state to state and personally I see the importance of a deep knowledge and understanding among us, and permanent embassies are a good tool for that.
thanks to Rebecka, who organized the visit, and to the Swidish Embassy which welcomed us.
1. http://www.un.org/en/documents/charter/chapter1.shtml
2.Jozef Batora and Brian Hocking, “EU-Oriented Bilateralism: Evaluating the Role of Member State Embassies in the European Union”
3.Jozef Batora and Brian Hocking, “EU-Oriented Bilateralism: Evaluating the Role of Member State Embassies in the European Union”
However it can be argued that, today, bilateral diplomacy is undermined by multilateralism and globalization as the case of the European diplomatic machinery taking precedent over bilateral diplomacy between EU members shows, posing the question whether EU bilateral missions fit within the European integration (3).
Still there is who oppose this view and today, 3rd of March, it has been interesting listening to the point of view of a diplomat about the role of embassies in the contemporary situation.
A diplomat from the Swedish embassy introduced us with his embassy and presented us the contemporary debate over the role of EU bilateral embassies in an integrated European scenario. He stressed that the people working within the Swedish embassy in London have been considerably reduced since the creation of the European diplomatic machinery has been formally established, especially because many of them have now been transferred to Brussels. In fact since the multilateral European diplomacy took over bilateral diplomacy, enormous budget cuts have been implemented, leaving any room for the specialists and increasing the job for the few diplomats still working for the embassy who have to be able to deal with many and different issues in a general way. Eventually this poses the question whether diplomats with a general, but not specialized, knowledge of the issues can operate in an efficient way as the specialists can do.
Then he argued that, although many people, some of his colleagues as well, question the role of permanent embassies in EU countries, bilateral diplomacy between EU members is a matter of understanding and clarification of European concerns between them, and that now a days European matters are brought to the table, so affirming that the diplomatic service now is not in a situation of vacuum but is accommodating the changing situation. Though, sadly he has to admit that some European embassies are closing down in some European capitals such as the Swedish in Dublin and Luxembourg.
On the second part of the meeting it has been interesting seeing how the Swedish diplomat dealt with our questions about the nature of embassies and the challenges they have to face.
He has been asked about the secret diplomacy that bilateralism encourages and he replayed that, although many countries are deeply involved within it, that is not the case of Sweden which carries a diplomacy as much open as it can.
Another question he has been asked was about the challenges the new technologies poses on diplomacy, yet he argued that physical presence is a key point for diplomatic relations.
He also has been asked whether multilateral diplomacy opposes to the pursuit of the promotion of national interests, and he absolutely agreed with it stating that when the issue is brought to the multilateral table, the outcome never reflects the national interests since it is the result of the “consensus” of the participants.
Overall it has been interesting listening to a diplomat, well aware of the debates going on about the role of bilateralism, defending his position in this challenging environment, stressing the understanding of the culture and hot issues that permanent embassies allow. In fact, though it can be argued that Europeans share a common history, culture and environment, we are very different state from state to state and personally I see the importance of a deep knowledge and understanding among us, and permanent embassies are a good tool for that.
thanks to Rebecka, who organized the visit, and to the Swidish Embassy which welcomed us.
1. http://www.un.org/en/documents/charter/chapter1.shtml
2.Jozef Batora and Brian Hocking, “EU-Oriented Bilateralism: Evaluating the Role of Member State Embassies in the European Union”
3.Jozef Batora and Brian Hocking, “EU-Oriented Bilateralism: Evaluating the Role of Member State Embassies in the European Union”
Sunday, 21 February 2010
the diplomacy for the people
In my view the most significant change in diplomacy can be considered the shift that occurred since it was just a matter of peace and war to its engagement in social issues, that is to say its shift from high politics to a mix of high and low politics.
Politics is becoming increasingly open to the public, and it is involving more and more people, and this is mainly because politics is about people, that is why diplomacy must engage more with the people and represent their interests since they are the active part of what is defined as sovereign state.
Moreover a social diplomacy which represents not only the national interests but the interests of the population as well is probably the key for what has been advocated since the end of the World War II: the real democratization of the world.
NGOs and IOs play an important role in social diplomacy, especially in those states that have a weak diplomatic machinery, such as many Third World Countries, and where the government abuses civil and human rights, in fact here is where their voices must be louder, louder than corruption and than bombs.
Social diplomacy is the main tool to advocate development and to challenge an unequal international system, to stop violation of human rights and to mediate in situation of conflicts.
However the international situation shows that social and development diplomacy still has to be developed and improved in order to achieve its goals, since the dialogue between the global North and the global South seems to be still weak.
Politics is becoming increasingly open to the public, and it is involving more and more people, and this is mainly because politics is about people, that is why diplomacy must engage more with the people and represent their interests since they are the active part of what is defined as sovereign state.
Moreover a social diplomacy which represents not only the national interests but the interests of the population as well is probably the key for what has been advocated since the end of the World War II: the real democratization of the world.
NGOs and IOs play an important role in social diplomacy, especially in those states that have a weak diplomatic machinery, such as many Third World Countries, and where the government abuses civil and human rights, in fact here is where their voices must be louder, louder than corruption and than bombs.
Social diplomacy is the main tool to advocate development and to challenge an unequal international system, to stop violation of human rights and to mediate in situation of conflicts.
However the international situation shows that social and development diplomacy still has to be developed and improved in order to achieve its goals, since the dialogue between the global North and the global South seems to be still weak.
Friday, 19 February 2010
Washington and Damasco re-establish diplomatic relations....what are the implications?
i use the occasion to try this blog since this week happened an important diplomatic change. i've just read tha Obama has re-engaged diplomatic relations with syria after 5 years of silence and ostility. after the accident in Beirut on the 14th of february 2005, the diplomatic relations between Washington and Damasco had been cut down. finally they re-astablished relations, but what i want to underline is the conditions of this relations, in fact syria wants that USA take opportune actions to try to sort out the Israel/Palestine issue with particular concern for the territory of Golan occupied by Israel since 1967; but what do the United States want back? clear! the want that Syria cuts it links with Theran since Damasco has always been an economic and ideological supporter of Iran. cut their links means a further isolation of Iran and an aggravation of the latter's situation.
what do you think about this diplomacy of return? I give you this if you give me this back? is this old or new diplomacy?
lets think about it; it is bilateral, it can be argued that in a kind of way it is exclusive, since it aims at the isolation of Iran, and it is about high politics, that is to say matters of security.
that's a strange world!
what do you think about this diplomacy of return? I give you this if you give me this back? is this old or new diplomacy?
lets think about it; it is bilateral, it can be argued that in a kind of way it is exclusive, since it aims at the isolation of Iran, and it is about high politics, that is to say matters of security.
that's a strange world!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)