Showing posts with label selles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label selles. Show all posts

Thursday, 29 April 2010

Understanding Diplomacy


Initially I viewed diplomacy as actors coming to an agreement to resolve conflict. So far , I have learnt that diplomacy is more than just negotiations between actors , it also an institution. Leguey –Feilleux states that “…the concept of diplomacy is the idea of communicating, interacting, maintaining contact and negotiating with states and other international organizations. Leguey- Feillleux : 2009, 1) The role of non state actors like NGO’s has also shown a dynamic change in diplomacy and has had a profound effect on how negotiation is conducted. For example, a group of NGO’s started the movement to ban landmines and support those affected by landmines . This culminated In the UN supporting the campaign and the OAU adopting the resolution. I have also learnt that diplomacy has its roots in antiquity but due to changing trends in international politics it has adapted to encompass several modes of diplomacy and other subjects including the environment and poverty . Technology has also played a role in shaping diplomacy as we know it today, creating greater circles of communication. Bilateral diplomacy still exists when communication needs to be guarded, and sometimes backchannels are used to secure talks. Another important feature that I have learnt about is the importance of the public at home and abroad which has led to the increased use of public diplomacy . As global politics change , we are likely to see diplomacy change and adapt to suit the international relations.
Sources
Leguey- Feilleux J.R, The Dynamic of Diplomacy , 2009, Lynne Rienner publishers

Thursday, 15 April 2010

The new diplomacy


Diplomacy has undergone a number of changes what with the effect of modern technology . However multilateral diplomacy represents a new development in diplomacy. It must be acknowledged that in terms of negotiations taking place between more than two polities , it is not that new as conferences can be dated back to Sparta in 430 B.C in ancient Greece and later during the Concert of Europe in 17th century Europe with Metternich, Castlereagh and other representatives meeting quite frequently. However what has changed is the proliferation of these Conferences after World war 2. The United nations has contributed to this as its activities mostly include conferences with country representatives. The newness of diplomacy comes
into play here with the fact that issues discussed at these conferences tend to cover a broader range of issues like trade and economics, tourism and other areas of interest as opposed to issues of war mainly in previous times .

According to Leguey –Feuilley this development is often attacked as being a corruption of diplomacy as a lot of the discussion take place under the eye of the media , but when discussions require confidentiality this type of diplomacy will be shielded away from publicity”(Leguey-Feuilley:2009, 218) Again the innovation is also represented by the inclusiveness of NGOs as partners in this type of diplomacy which is also directly linked to paradiplomacy ie the role of nonstate actors not only in conference diplomacy , that is , they are often included in conferences and sometimes form part of the body of government representatives at conferences. In the Earth Summit(1992) that took place in Rio De Janeiro to discuss climate issues , more members of NGO’s served and participated on government delegations than ever witnessed before . Leguey- Feuilly also explains that NGO representatives played a prominent role in the campaign to ban landmines as they were invited to join the French delegation at the 1996 Ottawa strategy conference(Leguey – Feuilley: 2009,107) It is evident that their input in multilateral diplomacy is quite important and represents a shift in that they have become part of the diplomatic process Apart from this we also have a situation where various sections of the UN are actively interacting with the rest of the world for example the UNESCO and UNDP actively engage with countries all over the world. Public diplomacy is also a new occurrence as more than ever diplomats are engaging with foreign publics to galvanize support for their country’s policies , way of life and culture . However in as much as it is a new development in diplomacy , multilateral diplomacy with its inclusivity is the most important development in diplomacy and it is expected to continue to evolve with the changes in global politics .
Sources
The new diplomacy Shaun Riordan 2003 Blackwell publishing
The dynamics of diplomacy Jean - Robert Leguey - Feuilley 2009 Lynne Rienner publishers

Saturday, 27 March 2010

Inroads into the Islamic world: Obamas Cairo speech (June 2009)


There have been tensions between the U.S and the Middle East and with the advent of the 9/11 bombings and the building tensions in Israeli – Palestinian relations are serving to further compound the problems, which have transcended from regional into global issues .


Berridge is of the idea that public diplomacy does not exist and that it is mere propaganda. The realist school of thought according to Riordan(2003) also asserts that “ Messages , in so far as they exist, are simply exercises in propaganda, designed to demonstrate the superiority of a given nations position .”(Riordan: 2003:121) However, linking this to Obama’s speech addressed to Cairo University, that simply does not hold water. In this speech he addresses not only Egyptians but the Middle-eastern world in general, drawing upon the significant input of the middle eastern region into modern civilization , the peaceful message of Islam and how these commonalities with Americas egalitarian principles should forge peace and not the descent into war .


Propaganda is the dispersion of a view that is biased in the midst of various voices stating the opposite, whereas this speech is in line with the truth as he engages in a dialogue with that part of the world. He also acknowledges the role of the West in destabilizing the middle east through colonialism and the cold war and talks of partnership, bridging the gap between the two cultures and aligning American policy to pursue peace . From this example we can see how Joseph Nye’s 1997 explanation of soft power as “…convincing others to follow, or getting them to agree to , norms and institutions that produce the desired behaviour ”( Riordan ;2003:120) links in with the use of public diplomacy to engage in dialogue and understanding with foreign publics.


Source

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/8082862.stm speech
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/8082730.stm-
The New Diplomacy, Shaun Riordan 2003 Polity Press
The Dynamics of Diplomacy, Jean- Robert Leguey –Feilleux , 2009, Lynne Rienner Publishers

Sunday, 7 March 2010

Kashmir: Conflict Resolution?


The timeline of the Indian and Pakistani conflict has spanned from the 1940’ up until today. The main issue of divergence is territorial over the Kashmir region which geographically lies between India and Pakistan. Militants of Afghani, Arab and Pakistani origin have proliferated and have since occupied the region waging conflict against the Indian Military. Amidst accusations of mass genocide and war crimes perpetrated by India, there have been more Kashmiris who are rallying for unification with Pakistan or the creation of a new Kashmiri state. In recent times it seems as though both camps are prepared to negotiate after waging one of the longest conflicts in modern history. The Prime minister of India has even commented positively by saying that anything could be negotiated and that the sky was the limit .

Old diplomacy has played a role in getting to this stage and is still relevant today , I say this because there was an element of secrecy as reports suggest that the spirit of negotiation between the two was hastened by secret back channel talks between the two countries that begun during General Musharraff’s tenure. The New Yorker claims that for several years envoys from both countries met secretly in London, Bangkok and Dubai negotiating the end of conflict in Kashmir which has now resulted in open talks between the two countries, mediated by President Obama. White clearly argues that there are many reason why secrecy is important by stating that “No good card or chess player reveals his or her hand in advance, and diplomatic negotiations are similar to these games in important respects” (White :2005:Page 390)

The bilateral element of the talks between India and Pakistan also show the relevance of old
diplomacy today. It is relevant in that Kashmir is a sensitive issue for both countries and to protect the negotiation process and avoid humiliation at home over possible solutions ,secrecy and exclusivity were essential at that time. One of the tenets of Old diplomacy is that the subject matter is often about high politics, the idea that war or open conflict might occur. In the case of Pakistan and India the posibble end to the conflict was discused, as the escalation of conflict caused by jihadists during the Mumbai bombings 2008 and pressure to retaliate had to be diffused. The fact that both of these countries are nuclear powers is a threat to regional and global peace in the event that these hostilities escalate to war.

However in as much as traditional diplomacy is still very much an important feature in international relations, in modern diplomacy there exists a space where governments have to gain the support at home and abroad so as to secure stability in the event of an agreement. Riordan further explains by stating that “Within the postmodern world, the breakdown of the division between domestic and foreign policy, the increasing importance of the media(both electronic and interactive)… mean that the public matter more than before”(Riordan 2003 :Pg123) . Already this expectation is being brought to bear on the Indian government as the Indian parliament are demanding accountability, openness and also public engagement in any concession in the Jammu –Kashmir region . It’s a very tight rope to walk on for any government involved In potential volatile negotiations of this nature, but it does reflect the relevance of old diplomacy in modern international relations.
Links and Sources:
http://www.newyorker.com/
http://www.washingtonpost.com/
http://www.newsweek.com/id/233419
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/
The New Diplomacy:Sean Riordan 2003
Diplomacy: Brian White in The Globalization of World Politics 3RD Edition by J. Bayliss and S. Smith 2005

Monday, 22 February 2010

On Diplomacy and multilateralism

A wind of change in terms of the multilateral aspect to negotiation in diplomacy signifies a major departure from the diplomacy of old. Communication and conflict negotiation in the diplomacy of old was bilateral in nature. Nations found this restrictive measure useful as negotiations were often bound by secrecy.

After the First World War the dynamics of diplomacy changed in that statesmen and diplomats had failed to halt the descent into war and more importantly, the fate of international politics and future conflict resolution could not solely be entrusted to them. The advent of the League of Nations later to be replaced by the United Nations 1945 signifies an important change in the nature of diplomacy. States and diplomats were still major actors on the international political scene as of old however they were to find themselves in an eventful market place, joined by other actors. These include intergovernmental actors consisting of government representatives as members and also non governmental actors consisting of private individuals , interest groups and international organizations .

The complexity of all these actors on the international stage signifies a major change; non governmental organizations have become key players in the game of international affairs. This can be exemplified by the role of anti globalization movements who organized riots in Seattle against the World Trade Organization (1999) to get their concerns across. As non governmental organizations are not bureaucratic in nature compared to the nature of traditional diplomacy, they are more adaptable on the political stage as they are not bound by bureaucratic rules. Non governmental organizations aim to represent interests of civil society as opposed to traditional diplomacy which is exclusive in nature to an extent. It must be remembered that the inclusivity and openness of conferences is a rather new development but the notion of conference meetings is not at all a new aspect of diplomacy, as it can be traced as far back as the Spartan Conference in 430B.C right up until today. However what has undoubtedly changed is the nature and ever increasing involvement of non governmental bodies in international political affairs.

Links
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/544447.stm
http://www.un.org/Docs/SG/agpeace.html